抱歉 这片子看得我职业病犯了，直到最后一分钟我都在期待剧情上的反转 到底Hanna有多么不可告人的苦衷还是情有可原的理由让她犯下反人类的罪行？结果是没有——它就是一个浪漫到一厢情愿的文艺片 任何一个法学院的一年级生都可以大声地告诉你有一种东西叫自然犯罪，杀人、防火、抢劫、强奸；这是不需要别人告诉你你在犯罪你也知道是犯罪的罪行，这和你文盲与否有任何一分钱关系吗？文盲就不知道杀人偿命吗？全片的逻辑到审判已经轰然倒塌，没有“如果你是我你会怎么做？”这个问题已经被回答过一千万次：“把枪口抬高一寸” ；所以如果一个人已经丧失了人性，她还有什么资格享受关于人的所有好事情，文学、诗歌、尊严、爱情？人性也许幽微复杂，但你不需要别人在你耳边朗读才知道不要杀人——人性也没有那么复杂。

车厢拥抱那一幕，在只有右上角昏暗灯光的几近黑暗里，男主额头疤痕下那双慢慢抬起进而闪着光的眼睛实在是迷人。

观众都知道老太太去海边了，就剧里的亲人完全不知道，就愣演。

电影三星半，这就是竹内结子的最后作品吗？实在太遗憾了啊

Superbly shocking. But I don't see any horror in Wicker Man, for the mood is as far from dread or fearful expectation as it might be. There isn't a shadow in sight. In fact, it's very bright, light and joyful, full of sweet and sensual folk songs and dances - slightly freakish but happily so. Most of the action takes place in flowery, open settings, irradiated by the sun and surrounded by the sea. I never completely bought into the murder or sacrifice of young Rowan, and speculated that the mystery will eventually clear up with no one getting hurt. But I took the bait and fell for the trap, the grandiose ending revealing how true madness, madness unaware of itself, was in play all along.